Back of the photograph reads “Father’s Grandfather, Barton”. The photograph was taken by H.M. Vaupel at 939 3rd Avenue in New York, indicating that Edward traveled to New York probably sometime after 1891. Herman Vaupel had a studio on 3rd Ave from 1883 - 1899 so, more precisely, this portrait was likely taken between 1891 and 1899. Edward Barton, age 52, moulder arrived in Liverpool from NY on 19 August 1893. The photograph was in the possession of Henry Harold’s daughter.